That’s what’s happening in Europe right now.
President Biden claims that his green agenda will create jobs, lower energy prices, make the U.S. more secure and leave the environment better off.
But a recent study tells a very different story. Heritage Foundation researchers have concluded that, over the next 18 years, Biden’s energy policies will result in $7.7 trillion in lost in GDP and 1.2 million fewer jobs.
But don’t take the experts’ word for it. Just look to Europe, which is further along in its government-imposed transition from conventional fuels to wind and solar power.
Germany is a good example of what happens when governments force consumers and businesses to rely on unreliable energy sources that are not yet commercially viable. The Association of German Chambers of Commerce and Industry reports that industry pessimism about the economy is as severe now as it was during the 2008 financial crisis and the initial covid lockdowns. Seventy-eight percent of businesses surveyed identified rising energy and raw material prices as one of the biggest risks they face, contributing to expectations that their businesses would deteriorate.
Another survey found that nearly 25 percent of Germany’s small- and medium-sized businesses are considering or actually relocating parts of their operations to another country.
Germany is transitioning to renewables and is purchasing natural gas from Russia, which has drastically reduced supplies. This is similar to President Biden’s plan to cut off domestic supplies of affordable and abundant fuels like gas and coal and force a transition to renewables while seeking to artificially ease the short-term pain by increasing imports and tapping the Strategic Petroleum Reserve.
Germany’s approach was to force a transition from conventional fuels and nuclear energy to less dense sources of energy such as wind and solar. This left the country unable to generate the power needed to fuel its modern industrial economy, forcing it to turn to foreign suppliers.
This dynamic is playing out across Europe. According to Goldman Sachs, Europe is entering an energy crisis that will be even worse than the 1970s. Goldman analysts forecast the typical European family’s energy bill next year will be three times what it was in 2021.
There is no doubt that geopolitical turmoil, such as Russia’s war on Ukraine, can spark price spikes. But policies that restrict gas, oil and coal development, both in the United States and Europe, exacerbate and extend energy price hikes and can create full blown energy crises.
European politicians disregarded citizens’ demand for affordable and abundant energy, opting to discourage traditional power generation in favor of their preferred “green” alternatives. As market power shifts away from consumers and toward government, private investment often follows. The result in Europe was under-investment in gas, oil, coal and nuclear. The money flowed instead to less reliable sources like wind and solar, which generally only operate under certain weather conditions.
European politicians realized they would face a voter revolt if citizens had to pay the full price of this policy, so they tried to ease the pain of transition by turning to what they believed would be a reliable source of energy: Russian oil and gas.
This was manageable, until Putin started shutting off natural gas supplies.
Europe’s problems were avoidable. The continent has substantial energy reserves: nearly 14 billion tons in proven coal reserves alone. That’s more than 85 times the EU’s total coal consumption last year (160 million tons).
Similarly, Europe has over 7 trillion cubic meters of natural gas resources. EU natural gas consumption in 2021 was approximately 397 billion cubic meters. Moreover, Europe is thought to have even more recoverable shale gas than the US.
That’s enough coal and natural gas to power European homes and businesses for many decades.
In addition, Europe has underutilized nuclear power. The continent has over 100 reactors providing about a quarter of its electricity consumption. But half of those reactors are in France, which gets 70 percent of its electricity from nuclear power. Half of the EU’s member states have no nuclear reactors at all.
Europe’s energy woes have little to do with access to affordable, reliable and clean energy and everything to do with pushing unrealistic energy policy choices. And European families and businesses are paying a steep price for those poor decisions.
President Biden has set America on the same, misguided path. Unless he changes course, we will wind up in the same, sorry predicament.
Jack Spencer is a senior research fellow in The Heritage Foundation’s Center for Energy, Climate, and Environment.