Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Smart Bombs: Military, Defense and National Security

Snake Island: Where the Russian Navy Goes to Die

Moskva
"Moskva" ("Moscow") (ex-"Slava", which means "Glory") is the lead ship of the Project 1164 Atlant class of guided missile cruisers in the Russian Navy. This warship was used in the 2008 Russia-Georgia War. The Black Sea. Sevastopol bay. This photo was taken from a boat.

The Curse of Snake Island Claims More Russian Vessels – On April 26, vengeful Furies began circling ominously over Snake Island bringing down from the heavens highly tangible woe upon Russian troops occupying the legendary burial ground of Achilles. 

Over the next seven days, air defense systems and electronic warfare apparatuses began exploding on the minuscule Black Sea islet, captured from Ukraine by the Russian Navy on February 24

These bolts from the blue culminated in the obliteration of two Raptor-class patrol boats on May 2nd, apparently dispatched to reinforce the beleaguered Russian garrison. 

The small vessels joined the powerful missile cruiser Moskva, leader of the assault on the island, on the floor of the Black Sea.

In fact, Moskva is the third cruiser to meet misfortune after attacking the island, the site of numerous battles, raids, and sinkings over three centuries.

“Russian Warship, go ___ yourself!”

Snake Island (or Zmiinyi in Ukrainian) measures merely one-sixth of a square kilometer, but the tiny landmass jutting 41 meters above sea level has for centuries been valued as a surveillance, navigation and communications outpost. That’s due to its strategic position 20 miles east of the mouth of the Danube River and 80 miles south of the Ukrainian port of Odessa. 

Control of the island passed back and forth between Moscow, Istanbul, Bucharest and Kyiv—and changed hands yet again on the opening day of Putin’s invasion of Ukraine at the hands of a Russian taskforce led by Black Sea Fleet’s flagship cruiser Moskva (11,490-tons), escorted by the corvette Vassily Bykov and frigate Admiral Essen. 

Buzzing by the island at 6 PM, they transmitted a message to the detachment of the Ukrainian border guards on the island, who lacked anti-ship weapons.

“You are in complete isolation and in effective range of our weapons. In case of resistance, you will be destroyed. Think of the children and loved ones who need you, who love you, who are waiting for you to return alive. It will soon be over and you can continue your normal life. Make the right decision, stay alive. Inform us on channel 16 about your intention to cooperate.”

Guardsman Roman Hrybov, a former Ukrainian marine and disco DJ from Cherkassy, famously messaged back “Russian warship, go f*ck yourself!”

The vessels raked the snow-covered island with their guns. The Moskva’s big twin-gun turret thumped out 130-millimeter shells while her 30-millimeter Gatling cannons spat rapid-fire fusillades, audible in an abbreviated cellphone video sent by the garrison. 

For good measure, a Su-24 bomber swooped in and cratered the outpost with bombs. 

Satellite photos show the barrage damaged or destroyed the lighthouse, communication towers, and red-roofed housing. Finally, after the guardsmen allegedly repulsed two Russian forays, Russian troops secured the island at 10 PM and seized the civilian rescue vessel, Sapphire

Kyiv claimed the detachment of 13 Ukrainian border guards were all killed, while Moscow reported capturing 82 Ukrainian troops.

A few days later, Kyiv conceded some of the guardsmen indeed survived. Finally, on March 24, nineteen Ukrainians captured there, including Hrybov, were repatriated in exchange for 11 Russian sailors. Hrybov’s defiant statement had become a rallying cry for Ukrainian resistance, immortalized in a postage stamp issued on April 12.

Ukraine

Meanwhile, Russia deployed personnel with electronic warfare systems, sensors, and communications equipment to the island, some ferried over by Ropucha-class tank-landing ships. The garrison could serve as a listening post and logistical base adjacent to the Ukrainian port of Odesa—one of Moscow’s chief objectives—and Romania, an important base for NATO fighters and missile defense systems.

To defend against air attack, a battery of Strela-10 (SA-13 Gopher) tracked vehicles armed with short-range heat-seeking missiles was deployed, and a Repellant-1 system: a 20-ton 6×6 truck mounting a retractable jammer that can disrupt remote-control signals used to control drones from up to 30 kilometers away.

The Curse of Snake Island

The three Russian warships that bombarded the island were soon seemingly beset by misfortunes. The Vassily Bykov was supposedly peppered by Ukrainian land-based rocket artillery while cruising near Odesa on March 7. Then April 3, a Neptune anti-ship missile allegedly damaged Admiral Essen on April 3. 

However, neither attack can be confirmed; whether Bykov was attacked, later images show she wasn’t damaged. More indisputable, however, was the fate of the Moskva. 

While patrolling a short distance east of Snake Island on April 13, the powerful cruiser built to sink U.S. aircraft carriers with long-range P-500 missiles was struck by two Ukrainian ground-launched Neptune missiles. A fire broke out in Moskva’s deck, likely fed by explosions from her large carrier-killer munitions. 

The powerful warship sank the following day while under tow. Her loss was more than an ill omen: with her went the long-range S-300F surface-to-air missiles protecting the Snake Island garrison and nearby warships from high-flying aircraft.

On April 26, Ukraine’s southern military district announced it had destroyed a command post and a Strela-10 vehicle on Snake Island using unspecified means.

Then on April 30, it reported three more Strela-10s were knocked out, a towed ZU-23-2 twin-barrel anti-aircraft gun, and the Repellant-1 counter-drone system strikes allegedly inflicted 42 casualties on the besieged garrison.

Imagery confirming at least some of these attacks was released in May, showing the targeting system of a TB2 Bayraktar combat drone engaging the ZU-23-2 cannon a Strela-10 with MAM-C and/or MAM-L laser-guided missiles from 7.2 and 8.3 kilometers away.

Telemetry visible in the bottom right corner of the Bayraktar videos suggests the attacks were launched from 7 and 8.3 kilometers (4.34-5.15 miles) away. The Strela-10’s missiles have a maximum 5 kilometers (3 miles) and max intercept altitude of 11,500 feet, while the Bayraktar’s service ceiling is around 25,000 feet.

Additional strike footage shows an attack on telecommunication equipment and an ammunition dump apparently full of rockets or missiles.

https://twitter.com/RALee85/status/1521631421412036608

The TB2’s UI is also clearly visible in videos released May 2 showing the attack on two Project 3160 Raptor boats, again from a range of 6.6-7 kilometers. The second boat is seen maneuvering evasively at high speed to no avail. The Raptor’s stabilized, electrooptically-guided 14.5-millimeter KPV-T machinegun is only effective against aerial targets out to 2 kilometers. 

Russia’s Navy began the war with 17 Raptors. Powered by U.S.-built Caterpillar turbodiesels and Rolls-Royce waterjets, they can attain speeds of 48 knots (55 mph) and have a typical operating radius of 100 miles. They’re used for coastal patrols, rescue, anti-sabotage defense, and high-speed troop transport with a capacity for 20 personnel.  Besides the two destroyed at Snake Island, a third Raptor was damaged near Mariupol on March 22 by an AT-4 anti-tank missile.

The Repellant-1 system on the island, however, should have been useable. Moscow indeed claims to have shot down three Bayraktars around Snake Island. That may mean the TB2 strikes were paid for in attrition of this valuable asset, but Russian anti-air claims are notoriously exaggerated, with more Bayraktar reported destroyed than Ukraine ever had.

It’s unclear how effective Russian forces on Snake Island remain. The Russian Navy will have to choose between doubling down on a base it clearly finds difficult to defend or withdrawing. Should the latter occur, Ukraine too will face the dilemma of whether to reestablish an outpost so vulnerable to attack, given the island’s small size and lack of concealing terrain. But given the island’s symbolic stature, it seems likely to remain a bone of contention.

At the intersection of empires

According to legend, Snake Island is the burial place of the Greek hero Achilles. After Achilles was famously felled by a blow to his heel, his mother Thetis spirited his body away from its funeral pyre for burial on Leuke (White Island). Thereafter, the island hosted a temple/shrine dedicated to Achilles, tended to Greek priests, as well as the occasional pirate band. 

Over a millennia later, on July 14, 1788, Russia’s newly-built Black Sea Fleet fought its first major battle by the island, then known as Fidonisi (“Snake”) after the white serpents infesting it. Despite outnumbering Russian ships of the line 10 to 2, the Turkish fleet withdrew after sustaining significant damage. 

In the 19th century, the island changed hands multiple times between Moscow, Istanbul, and finally Bucharest, during which a 12-meter-tall lighthouse was built atop the ruins of Achilles’s shrine.

When Romania joined the Entente alliance in World War I, it used a wireless station on Snake Island for communication with Russia. In May 1917 the Ottoman cruiser Midilli (formerly the German SMS Breslau) destroyed the outpost and its 19th-century lighthouse with her eight 150-millimeter guns and took 11 prisoners. 

Seven months later on January 20, 1918, after sinking two British monitors close to Imbros island, Midilli struck five mines and sank, taking 330 onboard with her, leaving only 133-162 survivors (sources differ).

In World War II, the Soviets and Romanians were now adversaries. Thus Russian air and sea forces attacked the island and its radio station, which was defended by a Romanian marine platoon armed with 45-, 76- and 122-millimeter coastal guns and two 37-millimeter anti-aircraft cannons. More effectively, Romanian and German ships laid two dense minefields around the island in the fall of 1942.

That failed to dissuade Soviet cruiser Voroshilov and escorting destroyer Soobrazitelny from plastering the outpost with 242 180- and 130-millimeter shells on December 1, 1942 somehow inflicting remarkably little damage. But while egressing, the Voroshilov struck two mines and was forced to limp back to port for repairs.

Over the next couple of weeks, the Snake Island mine barrages also destroyed two Soviet submarines, the 592-ton Shch-212 and the 208-ton M-31 with loss of 75 crew between them. Finally, in August 1944, Romanian troops abandoned the island, which fell under Soviet control.

Post-war Moscow held the island over Romanian objections, installing radars and navigational beacons. When the Soviet Union dissolved in 1991, the island passed into Kyiv’s control, though in the 2000s Romania revived its legal disputes over the island in the International Court of Justice. 

Meanwhile, Ukraine built-up infrastructure on the island, including a helicopter pad, a pier on its northwest corner, a marine research station on the northeastern tip, and the ‘town’ of Bile with  a variety of quality-of-life amenities.

Russia is therefore only latest occupier of this islet on the Black Sea at the intersection of several nations. We likely haven’t heard the last of Snake Island and the misfortunes of forces warring for control of it.

Sébastien Roblin writes on the technical, historical, and political aspects of international security and conflict for publications including The National InterestNBC NewsForbes.com, War is Boring, and 19FortyFive, where he is Defense-in-Depth editor.  He holds a Master’s degree from Georgetown University and served with the Peace Corps in China.  You can follow his articles on Twitter.

Written By

Sebastien Roblin writes on the technical, historical, and political aspects of international security and conflict for publications including the 19FortyFive, The National Interest, NBC News, Forbes.com, and War is Boring. He holds a Master’s degree from Georgetown University and served with the Peace Corps in China.  

12 Comments

12 Comments

  1. Eric-ji

    May 5, 2022 at 2:40 pm

    Maybe this ongoing story could be a sequel to “The Curse of Oak Island”.

  2. CK

    May 6, 2022 at 7:49 am

    You guys hear the Admiral Makarov frigate now also appears to be on fire?

    Imagine losing all these ships in your navy, in a landwar, against a country without a navy itself.

    Maybe they were worried the Moskva was feeling lonely?

    • Lee Ellak

      May 11, 2022 at 10:50 am

      You need to do your homework. Ukraine has a Navy.

  3. Alex

    May 6, 2022 at 8:19 am

    The fake with Neptunes was exposed long ago. There were no Neptune rockets and could not be.
    But let’s talk about how the Ukrainian border guards sent a Russian warship to hell:
    The President of Ukraine honored them with the title of Hero of Ukraine posthumously. However: all the Ukrainian border guards turned out to be alive, surrendered and gave interviews where they cursed the Ukrainian leadership.
    Now tell me what are the actors and production 🙂

  4. CK

    May 6, 2022 at 8:39 am

    Funny, nobody mentioned anything about Neptunes. Do you know something we don’t?

    Are you saying it was actually sunk? Careful Alex, loose lips sink ships!

    You don’t want trip to Siberia now do you?

  5. Alex

    May 6, 2022 at 9:29 am

    And now let’s hear the truth, not Bandera’s Nazi fakes:
    The Bandera Nazis of Ukraine rejoiced that they had arrested the Ukrainian independent journalist Anatoly Shariy in Spain. Anatoly Shariy moved his member on the lips of the Bandera Nazis and is already at large! This is democracy in Europe, and not lawlessness like you have in impoverished Ukraine, Bandera pigs 🙂

    • h

      May 6, 2022 at 12:39 pm

      The lawnessness and impoverishment in ukraine appears to be due to Russian soldiers looting temples, houses and businesses, as well as stealing grain and agricultural equipment.

      Then of course are all the atrocities against civilians committed by the Russian forces, but you already know all this, don’t you.

  6. CK

    May 6, 2022 at 11:34 am

    Lol, imagine anyone believing Russia is journalist friendly 😀

    You guys see the man arrested for holding an imaginary placard? What about the one who was holding a packet of ham?

    What a joke of a country.

  7. Alex

    May 6, 2022 at 12:46 pm

    German journalist Thomas Röper: Ukrainians are very afraid that the Russians will leave.
    The journalist spoke about the distortion of facts in the Western media:

    “I was three times in the south (Ukraine). The first trip was also to Melitopol. And so, on this trip, I was most impressed by the fact, or the fear that you see there in the eyes of people. And not among those who do not agree with the military operation, and according to my estimates, this is a minority. It is they who swear, the camera writes, and they will say how much they disagree. And those who agree are the majority.

    I see it in the squares, when there are hundreds of people, they walk past the soldiers and say in a whisper: “Thank you guys, don’t leave.” They are very afraid, and they said it directly. They are very afraid that the Russians will leave and there will be reprisals. What, in my understanding, happened in Bucha, by the way.

    And the fact that now, Alina said, from Mariupol is another such example. The woman was afraid to just speak the truth. Afraid that, God forbid, the Russians would leave and there would be reprisals. I don’t want to take too much time now, I just want to give one example, because the West always says it’s Russian propaganda if they say that Azov and other units of the Ukrainian troops use civilians as a “human shield”.

    I write in German, and the other day I read an article in the German magazine Spiegel, which is probably known to many. And there was a very surprising offer. So they wrote… Everything, of course, sounded very positive, but they wrote that in Mariupol… More precisely, they (the newspaper) were told by people in Zaporozhye who had come from Mariupol, telling them that their national battalions held them, “politely of course”, held peaceful residents to the basement, and took positions in the apartments above these basements. It sounds in the Western media as if they are protecting them. Excuse me, what is this? If the fighters take up their combat positions above the basements where civilians are sitting, and how voluntarily they went to this basement.

    Most people know the truth, but the Western media do not need this truth, they have a different manual, you need to do everything the other way around, and if it doesn’t work out the way America wants, you get sanctions, but the EU countries, not Russia, they will die after the first package of sanctions.

  8. CK

    May 6, 2022 at 7:57 pm

    Yes, Russia would know a lot about occupying houses while civilians cower downstairs in the basements, despairing at when it will be their turn to be shot in the back of the head or gang-raped, a tactic you savages have been honing well since WW2.

    • Olga J

      May 8, 2022 at 9:26 am

      Russian soldiers have been raping and pillaging in all wars including the present. The stories of the horror they inflicted on civilians have been told in much of eastern Europe. Get out of Ukraine, and quit your ‘nazi Ukraine’tirade. Russia’s excuses for invasion’s are so shallow and low in intellect.

  9. Lee Ellak

    May 11, 2022 at 10:57 am

    Using your lingo, Ukrainians also go to Snake Island to die.

    From TASS Russian news reporting:
    “During the operation to repel attacks on the island, four Ukrainian aircraft were downed in the air, including three Su-24 and one Su-27, three Mi-8 helicopters with paratroopers onboard and one Mi-24 helicopter. Also during the airborne landing attempt on May 8 night three Ukrainian Project 58181 Centaur-class armored assault craft with Ukraine’s Navy personnel were destroyed.”

    Remember in war, both sides bite.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Advertisement