Summary and Key Points: In 2005, the Swedish submarine HSwMS Gotland achieved a simulated “kill” against the USS Ronald Reagan during high-intensity naval exercises.
-Utilizing Air-Independent Propulsion (AIP), the Gotland operated almost silently, eluding the entire Carrier Strike Group’s sonar and helicopter screens.
-This event shattered assumptions about carrier invulnerability and highlighted a critical vulnerability: the Navy’s Cold War-era sensors were tuned for loud, fast nuclear subs, not ultra-quiet diesel-electrics.
-The exercise forced a total reevaluation of U.S. anti-submarine warfare (ASW) tactics, emphasizing detection in shallow, ambient-noise-heavy coastal waters.
How a Small Swedish Gotland-Class Submarine “Sank” the Nimitz-Class Aircraft Carrier USS Ronald Reagan
In 2005, the United States Navy conducted a series of naval war games to test how well its carrier strike groups could defend against submarines, an initiative to assess the range, resolution, and effectiveness of its sonar detection and anti-submarine weapons.
One of the most memorable exercises involved the Swedish diesel-electric submarine Gotland sinking a massive U.S. carrier in a simulated exercise.
Using its quiet diesel engine, the Swedish boat managed to elude detection and destroy the U.S. Navy’s USS Ronald Reagan.
While no ship was actually damaged, the event had a large impact on U.S. naval thinking and sharpened focus upon the growing effectiveness of quiet, non-nuclear submarines.
At the time, the USS Ronald Reagan was one of the newest and most advanced nuclear-powered aircraft carriers in the world.
Gotland-Class Fleet of Submarines. Image Credit: Creative Commons.
Gotland-Class. Image Credit: Saab.
By traveling in a carrier strike group, the Ronald Reagan was protected by guided-missile cruisers, destroyers, aircraft, and nuclear attack submarines.
Cold War Defenses
These defenses were primarily designed during the Cold War, when the main undersea threat came from large, fast, nuclear-powered Soviet submarines.
Inexpensive, older diesel-electric submarines such as the Gotland were not regarded as a threat comparable to the perceived Soviet threat.
The Gotland was able to elude helicopter, sonar, and surface warship sensors to find the “quiet space” and exploit the “gaps” in submarine detection.
The Gotland was equipped with air-independent propulsion (AIP), allowing it to operate underwater for extended periods without surfacing.
When running on battery power, the submarine was exceptionally quiet—often quieter than the ocean’s ambient noise.
WESTERN PACIFIC (Nov. 12, 2017) The aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71) transits the Western Pacific during a three-carrier strike force photo exercise. The USS Ronald Reagan (CVN 76), USS Theodore Roosevelt (CVN 71) and USS Nimitz (CVN 68) Strike Groups are underway and conducting operations in international waters as part of a three-carrier strike force exercise. The U.S. Navy has patrolled the Indo-Asia Pacific region routinely for more than 70 years promoting regional security, stability and prosperity. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Kelsey J. Hockenberger/Released)
PACIFIC OCEAN (Oct. 30, 2007) – USS Ronald Reagan (CVN 76) conducts rudder checks as part of the ship’s Board of Inspection and Survey (INSURV) following a six-month Planned Incremental Availability. All naval vessels are periodically inspected by INSURV to check their material condition and battle readiness. U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class M. Jeremie Yoder (RELEASED)
This mode made detection by traditional sonar systems extremely difficult, particularly in shallow or coastal waters.
During the war games, the Gotland was tasked with playing the role of an enemy submarine attempting to attack a U.S. carrier strike group.
In one widely cited exercise, the submarine successfully evaded the escorting ships and aircraft, maneuvered into firing position, and executed a simulated torpedo attack against the carrier.
In naval exercises, such an outcome is often referred to as a “kill,” meaning that, under real combat conditions, the targeted ship would likely have been disabled or sunk.
Reports of this simulated attack led to the dramatic claim that Gotland had “sunk” the USS Ronald Reagan.
Small Submarine Sinks U.S. Navy Aircraft Carrier in Drill
A relatively small, conventionally powered submarine had demonstrated the ability to threaten the most powerful surface warship ever built.
This event challenged longstanding assumptions within the U.S. Navy about undersea warfare and carrier invulnerability.
(Sept. 14, 2020)The aircraft carrier USS Ronald Reagan (CVN) 76 steams ahead during exercise Valiant Shield 2020. Valiant Shield is a U.S. only, biennial field training exercise (FTX) with a focus on integration of joint training in a blue-water environment among U.S. forces. This training enables real-world proficiency in sustaining joint forces through detecting, locating, tracking, and engaging units at sea, in the air, on land, and in cyberspace in response to a range of mission areas. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Nick Bauer)
The aircraft carrier USS Ronald Reagan (CVN 76) sails alongside amphibious assault carrier USS Tripoli (LHA 7) during a photo exercise for Valiant Shield 2022, June 12, 2022. Exercises like VS22 allow forces across the Indo-Pacific the opportunity to integrate Navy, Marine Corps, Army, Air Force and Space Force to train in precise, lethal, and overwhelming multi-axis, multi-domain effects that demonstrate the strength and versatility of the Joint Force. Tripoli is operating in the U.S. 7th Fleet area of operations to enhance interoperability with allies and partners and serve as a ready response force to defend peace and maintain stability in the Indo-Pacific region. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Peter Burghart)
To an equal or greater extent, the wargame’s findings reinforced the importance of the cost curve, as a less expensive single submarine sank a $13 billion carrier.
Several factors contributed to Gotland’s success. Its low acoustic signature made it difficult for sonar operators to distinguish it from background noise.
The aftermath of the exercise was arguably more important than the simulated attack itself.
The U.S. Navy used the experience to reevaluate the anti-submarine tactics and technologies it was employing with its Carrier Strike Groups.
The Navy not only re-examined its sensor technology, such as Variable Towed Array Sonar, but also refined its training methods. Greater emphasis was placed on detecting and tracking.
Future of Sonar
The incident also influenced broader strategic thinking. It underscored that advanced military power does not always require the largest or most expensive platforms.
Smaller nations operating modern conventional submarines could pose serious threats to even the most sophisticated navies.
For the United States, this reinforced the importance of preparing for asymmetric warfare, where adversaries exploit specific weaknesses rather than matching strength for strength.
The 2005 war game involving HSwMS Gotland and the USS Ronald Reagan did not result in the literal sinking of an aircraft carrier, but it did deliver a powerful symbolic blow.
By achieving a simulated kill during the exercise, the Swedish submarine exposed vulnerabilities in U.S. naval defenses and helped reshape American anti-submarine warfare priorities.
The event remains a frequently cited example of how realistic training and unexpected opponents can provide invaluable lessons—ones that may ultimately save lives and ships in real combat.
About the Author: Kris Osborn, Warrior Maven President
Kris Osborn is the President of Warrior Maven – Center for Military Modernization. Osborn previously served at the Pentagon as a highly qualified expert in the Office of the Assistant Secretary of the Army—Acquisition, Logistics & Technology. Osborn has also worked as an anchor and on-air military specialist at national TV networks. He has appeared as a guest military expert on Fox News, MSNBC, The Military Channel, and The History Channel. He also has a Masters Degree in Comparative Literature from Columbia University.
